I ran through the same calculations as Gary did a couple posts ago. I made a spreadsheet to compare the flow rates and different heads of pressure they create.
Looking through the available pumps I've come across a few that would work.
grundfos up15-100f 5.3gpm @ 1.1A (135W)
taco 009 gives me 6gpm @ 1.4A (161W)
grundfos ups26-99FC (speed #2) gives 7.5 gpm @ 1.5A (179W)
I'm still trying to dig through all the possibilities. However, I am leaning toward the UPS26-99FC at this point. Unless the power consumption ratings are way off, its very comparable pump wise to the UP26-64F, but the UP26-64F pulls 1.7A vs the 1.5A on the UPS26-99FC.
One thing I am thinking would probably be nice to have integrated into the pump is a check valve to prevent circulation when the pump is off. Its a relatively cheap option to add to the pump, and its one less thing I have to find fittings for and install.