I've finished this test and summed up the results from 2011 and 2012, a total of 12 weeks.
Date | Hours | Wh used | Timer | Wh/24h | Fridge temp min/max °C | Kitchen temp min/max °C |
24.02-03.03.2011 | 166.8 | 3758 | off | 540.7 | ?/? | ?/? |
03.03-10.03.2011 | 168.0 | 3700 | on | 528.6 | ?/? | ?/? |
10.03-17.03.2011 | 167.0 | 3864 | off | 555.3 | 3.9/5.9 | 16.7/18.7 |
17.03-24.03.2011 | 170.2 | 4204 | on | 592.8 | 3.5/7.1 | 16.5/19.8 |
02.02-16.02.2012 | 334.2 | 8097 | on | 581.5 | 2.6/6.7 | 17.2/20.9 |
16.02-01.03.2012 | 333.5 | 8429 | off | 606.6 | 2.3/4.4 | 16.1/19.4 |
01.03-15.03.2012 | 337.9 | 8024 | on | 569.9 | 2.3/6.4 | 16.0/20.4 |
15.03-29.03.2012 | 331.1 | 8285 | off | 600.5 | 2.1/6.5 | 16.0/18.8 |
Comments:
- The last week (17.03-24.03) of the 2011 test (timer on) saw lots of cooking, so the kitchen was slightly warmer and the refrigerator had more use. This noticeably increased energy consumption.
- The last two weeks (15.03-29.03) of the 2012 test (timer off) saw lower average kitchen temperatures. The weather was warm enough to keep the central heating from turning on more often than once every 1-2 days, so the house's average temperature was about 0.5°C lower than during the previous weeks. Notice how the kitchen's minimum temps get lower toward the end of the test.
- The timer itself uses a continuous 1W. It was removed during the 2011 "timer-off" tests, but left on during all 2012 tests.
- The three situations above skew the results in favor of the "timer-off" tests.
- The fridge's temps most likely maxed out when the door was open, not towards the end of the 6 hour off time when the timer was on. The thermometer's sensor was in the back, between water bottles, but when the door was open for a longer time, then warmer air had time to get deeper in.
- During the "timer-on" tests in 2012 I noticed that around 6:30am the refrigerator's compressor was not yet on, even though the timer turned the power back on around 6:00. The temperature inside the fridge was ~5.8°C. On one hand, this would suggest that at night it takes the fridge more than 6 hours to gain enough heat to turn on. On the other, during the day, or during the "timer-off" tests, I never noticed an inside temp as high as 5.8°C - the compressor usually turns on just below 5°C. This leads me to believe that our refrigerator has some sort of safety feature that keeps it from turning on within 30-60 minutes after power is restored.
- I noticed that the refrigerator's min/max were ~1.5°C lower in 2012 than in 2011. Maybe someone changed its settings?
- Comparing results between 2011 and 2012 showed an increase in daily power usage: It went from 572.0 to 603.6 Wh (+5.5%) with the timer off, and from 560.9 to 575.7 Wh (+2.6%) with the timer on. I was expecting a decrease from the extra insulation I added to back of the fridge, but I guess this was offset by the lowered temperature.
Summing up all of the raw results:
- Timer on (fridge off from midnight to 6am): Total of 24025 Wh consumed over 1010.3 hours gives 570.7 Wh/24h.
- Timer off (fridge on 24h per day): 24336 Wh consumed over 998.4 hours gives 585.0 Wh/24h (+2.5% more than timer on).
If the 2011 "timer-off" results are increased by the amount of power that the timer would have used (see comment #3), then we get:
- Timer on: 24025 Wh, 1010.3 h, 570.7 Wh/24.
- Timer off: 24670 Wh, 998.4 h, 593.0 Wh/24h (+3.9%).
If all of the tests which used the timer are reduced by the amount of power that it would have used, then we get:
- Timer on: 23015 Wh, 1010.3 h, 546.7 Wh/24.
- Timer off: 23672 Wh, 998.4 h, 569.0 Wh/24h (+4.1%).