I got out a tape measure and figure that the freezer is roughly 18.6 cubic feet
The US energy star ones roughly the same size are 400- 435 kwh/year
After two days running I'm at 3.02 kwh used or 551 kwh/year which costs me $44/year
taking a real quick look at sears.ca and the canadian energy star page which has different models then the US. I find a few options for replacement
KenmoreŽ/MD 14.8 cu. ft. Chest Freezer - Sears | Sears Canada 14.8 cf uses 357 kwh/year and costs $550. It would save me $15.50/year giving me a 35 year payback assuming no increase in electric and I ignore taxes on the freezer.
frigidaire makes
Capacity 11 - 20 | Chest | Freezers | Fridges & freezers | Appliances | Sears Canada same size but using 397 kwh/year and costing $580
this gives me a payback of 47 years.
Interestingly it's not energy star qualified according to sears but it's on the energy star list.
I see that I can go to a "full size" 24 cf freezer and use the same amount of power as my little one.
Doing all of this research says I shouldn't bother replacing this freezer until it dies or I decide it's not able to do what I need. The replacement will never last long enough to pay for its self in energy savings unless power bills go way way up.
I've looked this freezer over before and I can not find a thermostat setting anywhere on it. maybe I'll have to pull the thing out and look in by the compressor. Good time to clean it up while I'm at it.